The debate is won even before it started with fix blade always standing ahead of mechanical broadheads. But one cannot conclude without analyzing the pros and cons. The mechanical designs are constantly being evolved, and this has given more scope for the bowhunters to experiment. Most of the time a good mechanical broadhead could do fine, but at the time of getting a more specific aim, it is time to opt for the fixed blade as it offers the decisive killing guarantee. The debate on whether best mechanical broadhead or fix blade is ideal for a kill is elaborated after analyzing the psychology behind bowhunting listed in www.academia.edu/4143395/The_Psychology_of_Bowhunting
The surface area of the blade affects the flying accuracy in a fixed blade. This could be a disaster in wind speed of 265 feet/second and more. This could lead to frustration and lack of efficiency in killing. In the case of mechanical head, the exposure of the blade surface is very minimal. It offers swift movement in the air without any effects of aerodynamic drag as the rear of the arrow steers forward. The deviation if any in the arrow flight does not imbalance the course giving greater scope to hit the target precisely.
In today’s fast-paced world where everything is quick and accurate, people look to save time in every aspect, and this is true in the case of shooting as well. The mechanics behind the mechanical design sets your band on target instead of wasting tons of time adjusting the bow and tuning only to miss the target. Mechanical broadhead does have its fan following for its precision and time-saving ability.
Though, one disadvantage is that it has not delivered efficient killing all the time. Some of the heads are fragile and comes with poor blade mechanics resulting in retarded penetration not leaving scope for lethal wound for a quick kill. Irrespective of the accuracy, the broadhead should penetrate deep and stay together for an accurate kill. Though, today high-quality engineering has changed the scenario with better ones arriving in the market.
It depends on the strength than the flight performance. Here, the blade is supported throughout its length and not at one point alone. Moreover, it comes with no moving component. Any moving mechanism can only make the blade weak. Fixed blades are reliable and intact offering the best of aim and impact on the kill. The innovation in the field offers excellent aerodynamic character. Although well designed mechanical head can outshine fixed blade, a superior quality fixed blade can perform better than poor mechanical heads as the blades are not closed during flight causing inconsistency in the aim.
Despite their advantages and disadvantages, the debate continues. There is a wide range of choice in both the blades leaving the choice to the hunter. The ultimate aim of the hunter is to achieve a quick kill in a humane manner and in this case broadhead selection is crucial. Various broadheads are discussed at https://www.astraightarrow.net/ to promote a humane kill.